glsl: Convert ir_call to be a statement rather than a value.

Aside from ir_call, our IR is cleanly split into two classes:
- Statements (typeless; used for side effects, control flow)
- Values (deeply nestable, pure, typed expression trees)

Unfortunately, ir_call confused all this:
- For void functions, we placed ir_call directly in the instruction
  stream, treating it as an untyped statement.  Yet, it was a subclass
  of ir_rvalue, and no other ir_rvalue could be used in this way.
- For functions with a return value, ir_call could be placed in
  arbitrary expression trees.  While this fit naturally with the source
  language, it meant that expressions might not be pure, making it
  difficult to transform and optimize them.  To combat this, we always
  emitted ir_call directly in the RHS of an ir_assignment, only using
  a temporary variable in expression trees.  Many passes relied on this
  assumption; the acos and atan built-ins violated it.

This patch makes ir_call a statement (ir_instruction) rather than a
value (ir_rvalue).  Non-void calls now take a ir_dereference of a
variable, and store the return value there---effectively a call and
assignment rolled into one.  They cannot be embedded in expressions.

All expression trees are now pure, without exception.

Signed-off-by: Kenneth Graunke <[email protected]>
Reviewed-by: Eric Anholt <[email protected]>
Reviewed-by: Ian Romanick <[email protected]>

1 files changed, 25 insertions, 7 deletions

diff --git a/src/glsl/ir_reader.cpp b/src/glsl/ir_reader.cpp
index e66ae470438..7ce683ef7d3 100644
--- a/src/glsl/ir_reader.cpp
+++ b/src/glsl/ir_reader.cpp
@@ -51,11 +51,11 @@ private:
    ir_variable *read_declaration(s_expression *);
    ir_if *read_if(s_expression *, ir_loop *);
    ir_loop *read_loop(s_expression *);
+   ir_call *read_call(s_expression *);
    ir_return *read_return(s_expression *);
    ir_rvalue *read_rvalue(s_expression *);
    ir_assignment *read_assignment(s_expression *);
    ir_expression *read_expression(s_expression *);
-   ir_call *read_call(s_expression *);
    ir_swizzle *read_swizzle(s_expression *);
    ir_constant *read_constant(s_expression *);
    ir_texture *read_texture(s_expression *);
@@ -349,6 +349,8 @@ ir_reader::read_instruction(s_expression *expr, ir_loop *loop_ctx)
       inst = read_if(list, loop_ctx);
    } else if (strcmp(tag->value(), "loop") == 0) {
       inst = read_loop(list);
+   } else if (strcmp(tag->value(), "call") == 0) {
+      inst = read_call(list);
    } else if (strcmp(tag->value(), "return") == 0) {
       inst = read_return(list);
    } else if (strcmp(tag->value(), "function") == 0) {
@@ -522,8 +524,6 @@ ir_reader::read_rvalue(s_expression *expr)
       rvalue = read_swizzle(list);
    } else if (strcmp(tag->value(), "expression") == 0) {
       rvalue = read_expression(list);
-   } else if (strcmp(tag->value(), "call") == 0) {
-      rvalue = read_call(list);
    } else if (strcmp(tag->value(), "constant") == 0) {
       rvalue = read_constant(list);
    } else {
@@ -611,10 +611,20 @@ ir_reader::read_call(s_expression *expr)
 {
    s_symbol *name;
    s_list *params;
+   s_list *s_return = NULL;
 
-   s_pattern pat[] = { "call", name, params };
-   if (!MATCH(expr, pat)) {
-      ir_read_error(expr, "expected (call <name> (<param> ...))");
+   ir_dereference_variable *return_deref = NULL;
+
+   s_pattern void_pat[] = { "call", name, params };
+   s_pattern non_void_pat[] = { "call", name, s_return, params };
+   if (MATCH(expr, non_void_pat)) {
+      return_deref = read_var_ref(s_return);
+      if (return_deref == NULL) {
+	 ir_read_error(s_return, "when reading a call's return storage");
+	 return NULL;
+      }
+   } else if (!MATCH(expr, void_pat)) {
+      ir_read_error(expr, "expected (call <name> [<deref>] (<param> ...))");
       return NULL;
    }
 
@@ -644,7 +654,15 @@ ir_reader::read_call(s_expression *expr)
       return NULL;
    }
 
-   return new(mem_ctx) ir_call(callee, &parameters);
+   if (callee->return_type == glsl_type::void_type && return_deref) {
+      ir_read_error(expr, "call has return value storage but void type");
+      return NULL;
+   } else if (callee->return_type != glsl_type::void_type && !return_deref) {
+      ir_read_error(expr, "call has non-void type but no return value storage");
+      return NULL;
+   }
+
+   return new(mem_ctx) ir_call(callee, return_deref, &parameters);
 }
 
 ir_expression *